top of page

From 94th Percentile on TPT in 2 Months To 6656 Best Store and No Time to Grow

Writer: Justin Allemang [Cashman MS]
Justin Allemang [Cashman MS]
Sep 18
8 min read

I hit the 94th percentile on TPT in 2 months, saw my store ranked around 6,656, and instead of calmly building a beautiful business plan, I stared at the screen like a raccoon holding a shiny spoon.


Proud? Yes.


Confused? Also yes.


Ready to scale? Absolutely not. I have lesson plans, life plans, laundry piles with their own zip codes, and a brain full of product ideas that arrive at 11:47 p.m. like tiny caffeinated gremlins.


This is the weird part of growing a TPT store. The store can start moving before your life has space for it.


And nobody talks enough about that part.


The TPT percentile jump felt amazing and slightly rude


The 94th percentile felt like a little confetti cannon went off in my seller dashboard.


Two months in, that number told me something was working. Buyers were finding products. Products were converting. The store had enough traction to register in a meaningful way.


Then came the store rank.


6,656.


Which is both very cool and also hilarious because it sounds like the number assigned to a background character in a dystopian teacher marketplace novel.


“Congratulations, Seller 6656. Please report to the laminator.”

The thing about a TPT Store Percentile Ranking is that it gives you a quick comparison point, but it doesn’t tell the whole story. Percentile can show momentum. Rank can show position. Neither one tells you whether you slept, ate a vegetable, or updated that one product thumbnail from 2019 energy.


Numbers are useful, but they’re not a business plan.


They’re more like the check engine light. Sometimes it means, “Great job, keep going.” Sometimes it means, “Please stop adding ideas to your Notes app and drink water.”


Growth creates a new problem, which is time


When a TPT store starts gaining traction, the obvious advice is:


  • Add more products.

  • Update covers.

  • Improve previews.

  • Bundle related resources.

  • Start blogging.

  • Build an email list.

  • Make pins.

  • Refresh SEO.

  • Create seasonal versions.

  • Raise prices.

  • Test thumbnails.

  • Expand to physical products.


Cool. Great. Love that.


Also, am I supposed to do this during my lunch break while eating crackers over a keyboard?


This is the part where Balancing Teaching and Side Hustles becomes less motivational poster and more survival sport. Teaching already uses the “full human” version of your brain. TPT wants the creative brain, the business brain, the tech brain, the customer service brain, and the part of the brain that remembers where you put the Canva file.


If you’re growing but have no time, you don’t need 27 more tasks.


You need a filter.


The question changes from, “What could I do next?” to “What is worth doing next?”


That one question saves sanity.


The trap is thinking every idea deserves immediate attention


I have so many ideas right now.


Physical products. Better bundles. Blog posts. Seasonal add-ons. Maybe a printed planner. Maybe classroom posters. Maybe task cards in a cute box. Maybe a resource line that has matching digital and print options.


My brain is basically a room full of kindergarteners holding glitter.


But not every idea gets to be first in line.


A growing store can make every idea feel urgent because now there’s proof that people might buy. That’s exciting. It’s also how you accidentally build 14 half-finished projects and one Canva folder named “NEW NEW FINAL ACTUAL FINAL.”


Here’s the filter I’m using:


  1. Does this idea connect to a product that already sells?

  2. Can I make it without learning five new systems?

  3. Will it help buyers use what they already bought?

  4. Can it earn without constant babysitting?

  5. Can I finish a small version in one tired evening or one focused weekend?


If the answer is no, it goes into the parking lot.


Not the graveyard. The parking lot.


The idea can wait with snacks.


Passive income for teachers is real, but not magical


Let’s talk about the phrase Passive Income for Teachers because it has done some emotional damage on the internet.


TPT income can become more passive than hourly tutoring or selling custom lesson plans. A buyer can purchase a digital resource while you’re sleeping, grocery shopping, or pretending you don’t see the unread emails.


That part is real.


But the setup is not passive.


Creating a strong resource takes time. Writing product descriptions takes time. Making previews takes time. Updating old files takes time. Answering buyer questions takes time. Fixing the typo you somehow missed after checking the resource 800 times takes time and humility.


Passive income is not “do nothing and make money.”


It’s more like planting perennials.


You do the work up front, water things, prune the weird bits, and eventually some products bloom without needing your constant attention. But if you disappear forever, weeds move in. Weeds love abandoned product listings. They bring friends.


What I would do first if I had exactly 3 spare hours


When time is tight, the best TPT Seller Tips are boring in the most useful way. They are not glamorous. They do not require a ring light. They will not make you feel like a CEO sipping iced coffee in linen pants.


They work anyway.


If I had 3 hours this week, I would not start a brand-new product line.


I’d improve what already has proof.


Here’s the 3-hour plan.


Hour 1 would go to the top product


Pick the product getting the most views, sales, or wishlists.


Do one improvement:


  • Add a clearer preview.

  • Update the cover.

  • Add a page of directions.

  • Include an answer key if it needs one.

  • Improve the product description with specific grade levels and use cases.

  • Add a few photos or mockups if allowed and helpful.


A product that already sells is like a student who raises their hand. Pay attention to that one first.


Hour 2 would go to a simple bundle


Look for 2 to 5 related products.


If they solve the same classroom problem, bundle them.


Bundles help buyers because they save decision time. They help sellers because they can increase order value without creating something from scratch.


A bundle also gives you another searchable listing.


That’s less “build a new empire” and more “use the bricks already sitting in the driveway.”


Hour 3 would go to one tiny marketing asset


Not a full content calendar. Absolutely not.


One asset.


Maybe:


  • A blog post outline.

  • A short Pinterest-friendly description.

  • A product update email draft.

  • A better preview thumbnail.

  • A seasonal note added to the listing.


Tiny counts.


Tiny is how a business grows when your calendar is packed tighter than a classroom pencil sharpener in September.


Expanding into physical products sounds fun and feral


I keep thinking about Expanding TPT to Physical Products.


On paper, it makes sense. If a digital resource sells, maybe the physical version could sell too. Teachers love ready-to-use materials. Parents like hands-on learning kits. Homeschool families often want printable resources without personally becoming a part-time print shop.


Physical products could include:


  • Printed task cards

  • Laminated centers

  • Classroom posters

  • Flashcards

  • Student workbooks

  • Teacher planners

  • Learning kits

  • Binder-ready intervention packs


Very cute. Very exciting.


Also, physical products add new problems.


Now you’re dealing with printing costs, packaging, shipping, storage, returns, damaged items, production time, and inventory. Digital products can be updated with a file upload. Physical products might require a reprint, a new supplier, or a small cry in the pantry.


This doesn’t mean physical products are a bad idea.


It means they need a test before they get a throne.


The safest way to test a physical product line


I don’t want to order 300 units of anything unless I’m very sure. My garage does not need to become a tiny warehouse run by vibes.


A safer path is to validate demand first.


Start with a product that already sells digitally. Then test interest in a physical version using the smallest version possible.


That might look like:


  • A printable resource upgraded into a bound workbook through a print-on-demand service

  • A small batch of 25 classroom poster sets

  • A laminated center kit offered seasonally

  • A pre-order from an existing audience

  • A local test with teachers you know personally

  • A simple “coming soon” interest form linked from a blog post or email


The goal is not perfection.


The goal is proof.


A physical product line needs margins that make sense. If printing, packaging, platform fees, and shipping eat the profit, the product is a craft project with invoices.


Cute, but rude.


Before going all in, I’d want to know:


Question

Why it matters

What does it cost to make one unit?

Pricing has to cover production and profit.

How long does it take to pack and ship?

Time is part of the cost.

Can someone else produce it later?

Growth gets messy if every order needs your hands.

Does the digital version already sell?

Existing demand lowers the guesswork.

Will buyers pay enough for convenience?

Physical products need higher prices to survive.


That last one matters most.


A printed product has to be convenient enough that someone pays for it instead of printing it at school while whispering, “Please don’t jam, please don’t jam.”


Blogging helps, even when I barely have time for it


I barely have time to blog.


And yet, here we are.


Blogging is my therapy. It gets the ideas out of my head and into a place where they stop yelling. Some people count sheep. I draft headings.


A blog can also support a TPT store in a practical way. It gives you a place to explain how to use a resource, show classroom examples, answer common questions, and build search traffic over time.


A blog post does not need to be a literary masterpiece. This is not a candlelit essay contest judged by the ghost of E.B. White.


It needs to be useful.


A simple blog post can cover:


  • How to use one product in a 30-minute lesson

  • Five ways to differentiate a resource

  • What to prep before teaching a skill

  • Common student mistakes and how to fix them

  • A seasonal roundup of related materials

  • A behind-the-scenes look at why a resource was created


That’s enough.


One post can support one product. One post can become an email. One post can become product description language. One post can become a pin or short caption later.


The trick is not writing more.


The trick is making each piece work harder than a glue stick in April.


The no-time growth plan I can actually live with


I cannot build the fantasy version of this business right now.


That version wakes up early, meal preps, batch creates 12 products, sends weekly emails, drinks enough water, and knows where all the chargers are.


Suspicious behavior.


The real version needs a plan that works inside a busy life.


Here’s the plan I can live with.


Pick one store task per week


Only one.


Not one category. One task.


Examples:


  • Update one product cover.

  • Write one better preview.

  • Bundle three related products.

  • Add answer keys to one resource.

  • Draft one blog post.

  • Improve one product description.

  • Create one freebie that connects to a paid product.


A store grows through completed tasks, not dramatic planning sessions with 19 tabs open.


Keep a product parking lot


Every idea goes into one document.


Mine needs categories because the ideas are breeding.


Possible sections:


  • Digital products

  • Blog posts

  • Physical products

  • Bundles

  • Seasonal updates

  • Freebies

  • Email ideas

  • “What was I thinking?” ideas


That last category is vital. Some ideas need time to reveal whether they are genius or just bedtime confetti.


Follow the money gently


This phrase sounds intense, but it’s simple.


Look at what already gets sales, clicks, or wishlists. Make more around that topic before jumping to something unrelated.


If a classroom management resource sells, related products might include routines, posters, parent notes, or editable templates.


If reading comprehension passages sell, related products might include seasonal sets, differentiated versions, or a physical workbook test.


The buyer already showed you a trail. You don’t have to wander into the woods holding a clipboard.


Build tiny systems


A system can be very small.


For example:


  • A product upload checklist

  • A Canva cover template

  • A blog post outline

  • A naming format for files

  • A pricing note for bundles

  • A folder for product updates


Small systems save future brain cells. Brain cells are precious. Mine are currently unionizing.


The win is real, even if the pace is slow


Going from new store energy to the 94th percentile in 2 months is worth celebrating.


Being ranked 6,656 is worth laughing about and celebrating too. Both can be true. It’s a milestone and a meme.


The hard part is accepting that growth doesn’t mean you suddenly have more hours. It means your limited hours matter more.


So I’m not going to chase every idea at once.


I’m going to improve what’s already working. I’m going to write when I can. I’m going to test physical products carefully. I’m going to let the parking lot hold the wild ideas until they’re ready.


And tonight, if blogging is the thing that helps my brain power down, I’ll take it.


Some people use sleep masks. I use Markdown and mild panic.


Progress counts either way.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page